Forum › Fantastyka › Star Trek › Najlepszy odcinek lub film Star Trek
Kolejny ranking filmów ST:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=674yLJQCUDw
I jeszcze jeden subiektywny ranking filmów ST:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C4bPapKPPqE
Obecne listy odcinków mających od 8 wzwyż, dla kolejnych serii ST (i pokrewnych) według IMDB:
TOS
1. The City on the Edge of Forever - 9,2
2. Mirror, Mirror - 9
3. Balance of Terror - 8,8
4. The Trouble with Tribbles - 8,8
5. Space Seed - 8,7
6. Amok Time - 8,6
7. The Doomsday Machine - 8,6
8. Journey to Babel - 8,5
9. The Enterprise Incident - 8,4
10. The Devil in the Dark - 8,3
11. The Menagerie: Part I - 8,2
12. All Our Yesterdays - 8,1
13. Errand of Mercy - 8,1
14. The Menagerie: Part II - 8,1
15. A Taste of Armageddon - 8
16. The Corbomite Maneuver - 8
17. The Tholian Web - 8
18. The Ultimate Computer - 8
TAS
1. Yesteryear - 8
TNG
1. The Inner Light - 9,4
2. The Best of Both Worlds - 9,3
3. The Best of Both Worlds Part II - 9,2
4. Yesterday's Enterprise - 9,2
5. The Measure of a Man - 9,1
6. All Good Things... - 9
7. Cause And Effect - 8,9
8. Chain Of Command, Part II - 8,9
9. Q Who - 8,9
10. I Borg - 8,8
11. Parallels - 8,8
12. Tapestry - 8,8
13. Darmok - 8,7
14. Lower Decks - 8,7
15. Deja Q - 8,5
16. Relics - 8,5
17. Ship In A Bottle - 8,5
18. The Offspring - 8,5
19. The Pegasus - 8,5
20. Timescape - 8,5
21. Redemption II - 8,4
22. Redemption - 8,4
23. The Defector - 8,4
24. The Drumhead - 8,4
25. Time's Arrow - 8,4
26. Chain Of Command, Part I - 8,3
27. Family - 8,3
28. Reunion - 8,3
29. The Next Phase - 8,3
30. Unification II - 8,3
31. Clues - 8,2
32. Conundrum - 8,2
33. Sins of The Father - 8,2
34. Time's Arrow, Part II - 8,2
35. Unification I - 8,2
36. Conspiracy - 8,1
37. Data's Day - 8,1
38. Descent - 8,1
39. Elementary, Dear Data - 8,1
40. First Contact - 8,1
41. Frame of Mind - 8,1
42. Sarek - 8,1
43. The Wounded - 8,1
44. A Matter Of Honor - 8
45. Face Of The Enemy - 8
46. The Chase - 8
47. The Nth Degree - 8
48. Who Watches The Watchers - 8
DS9
1. In the Pale Moonlight - 9,4
2. Trials and Tribble-ations - 9,3
3. The Visitor - 9,1
4. The Way of the Warrior - 9
5. Call to Arms - 9
6. Duet - 9
7. Sacrifice of Angels - 9
8. What You Leave Behind - 8,9
9. Far Beyond the Stars - 8,9
10. The Die Is Cast - 8,9
11. By Inferno's Light - 8,8
12. In Purgatory's Shadow - 8,7
13. Tacking into the Wind - 8,7
14. The Siege of AR-558 - 8,6
15. A Time to Stand - 8,5
16. Favor the Bold - 8,5
17. Improbable Cause - 8,5
18. Rocks and Shoals - 8,5
19. Little Green Men - 8,4
20. The Jem'Hadar - 8,4
21. Paradise Lost - 8,3
22. The Changing Face Of Evil - 8,3
23. The Search, Part I - 8,3
24. Apocalypse Rising - 8,2
25. Broken Link - 8,2
26. Hard Time - 8,2
27. Homefront - 8,2
28. Inquisition - 8,2
29. Inter Arma Enim Silent Leges - 8,2
30. It's Only a Paper Moon - 8,2
31. Tears of the Prophets - 8,2
32. The Adversary - 8,2
33. The Dogs of War - 8,2
34. The Search, Part II - 8,2
35. The Wire - 8,2
36. Treachery, Faith and the Great River - 8,2
37. Necessary Evil - 8,1
38. The Magnificent Ferengi - 8,1
39. When It Rains... - 8,1
40. Whispers - 8,1
41. Children of Time - 8
42. The House of Quark - 8
43. To the Death - 8
VOY
1. Blink of an Eye - 9
2. Scorpion - 8,9
3. Scorpion: Part II - 8,8
4. Living Witness - 8,7
5. Message in a Bottle - 8,7
6. Timeless - 8,7
7. Year of Hell - 8,7
8. Drone - 8,6
9. Year of Hell: Part II - 8,6
10. Dark Frontier - 8,5
11. Endgame - 8,5
12. Distant Origin - 8,5
13. Relativity - 8,5
14. Tinker Tenor Doctor Spy - 8,5
15. Pathfinder - 8,4
16. Death Wish - 8,3
17. Equinox - 8,3
18. Latent Image - 8,3
19. Deadlock - 8,2
20. Eye of the Needle - 8,2
21. Future's End - 8,2
22. Shattered - 8,2
23. Equinox: Part II - 8,1
24. Future's End, Part II - 8,1
25. Life Line - 8,1
26. One - 8,1
27. Someone to Watch Over Me - 8,1
28. Hope and Fear - 8
29. Prey - 8
30. Scientific Method - 8
31. Worst Case Scenario - 8
ENT
1. Twilight - 8,6
2. Azati Prime - 8,5
3. Carbon Creek - 8,5
4. Countdown - 8,5
5. Regeneration - 8,5
6. United - 8,5
7. Zero Hour - 8,5
8. Babel One - 8,4
9. Kir'Shara - 8,4
10. Proving Ground - 8,4
11. Shockwave, Part I - 8,4
12. Similitude - 8,4
13. The Council - 8,4
14. In a Mirror, Darkly - 8,3
15. In a Mirror, Darkly, Part II - 8,3
16. The Aenar - 8,3
17. The Expanse - 8,3
18. Shockwave, Part II - 8,2
19. The Forge - 8,2
20. Awakening - 8,1
21. Damage - 8,1
22. Future Tense - 8,1
23. Stratagem - 8,1
24. Terra Prime - 8,1
25. Dead Stop - 8
26. Dear Doctor - 8
27. Divergence - 8
28. Fallen Hero - 8
29. The Andorian Incident - 8
NV/P2
1. World Enough and Time - 8,3
STC
1. To Boldly Go: Part II - 9,3
2. To Boldly Go: Part I - 9,1
3. Fairest of Them All - 8,9
4. What Ships Are For - 8,6
5. Lolani - 8,3
6. Still Treads the Shadow - 8
Prelude to Axanar - 8,3
DSC
1. If Memory Serves - 8,2
2. Such Sweet Sorrow, Part 2 - 8,2
3. Vaulting Ambition - 8,1
4. What's Past Is Prologue - 8,1
PIC
1. Nepenthe - 8,3
2. Remembrance - 8,2
3. The Star Gazer - 8
4. Penance - 8
LD
1. No Small Parts - 8,7
2. wej Duj - 8,7
3. First First Contact - 8,7
4. Hear All, Trust Nothing - 8,6
5. The Stars at Night - 8,6
6. I, Excretus - 8,4
7. Reflections - 8,1
8. Crisis Point - 8,1
9. Crisis Point 2: Paradoxus - 8
PRO
1. Supernova, Part 1 - 8,9
2. Supernova, Part 2 - 8,8
3. Kobayashi - 8,4
4. A Moral Star, Part 2 - 8,4
5. All the World's a Stage - 8,3
6. Crossroads - 8,3
7. Mindwalk - 8,3
8. Time Amok - 8,2
9. A Moral Star, Part 1 - 8,1
10. Asylum - 8
SNW
1. A Quality of Mercy - 9,1
2. Memento Mori - 8,4
3. Strange New Worlds - 8,2
4. All Those Who Wander - 8,2
5. Spock Amok - 8,1
6. Children of the Comet - 8
B5
1. Severed Dreams - 9,6
2. War Without End: Part Two - 9,4
3. Z'ha'dum - 9,4
4. Endgame - 9,3
5. Sleeping in Light - 9,2
6. The Coming of Shadows - 9,2
7. The Long, Twilight Struggle - 9,2
8. War Without End: Part One - 9,2
9. Point of No Return - 9,1
10. The Fall of Night - 9,1
11. In the Shadow of Z'ha'dum - 9
12. Into the Fire - 9
13. No Surrender, No Retreat - 9
14. The Fall of Centauri Prime - 9
15. The Long Night - 9
16. Between the Darkness and the Light - 8,9
17. Interludes and Examinations - 8,8
18. Messages from Earth - 8,7
19. Chrysalis - 8,6
20. Movements of Fire and Shadow - 8,6
21. Rising Star - 8,6
22. Shadow Dancing - 8,6
23. The Face of the Enemy - 8,6
24. And All My Dreams, Torn Asunder - 8,5
25. Babylon Squared - 8,5
26. Falling Toward Apotheosis - 8,5
27. And the Rock Cried Out, No Hiding Place - 8,4
28. Intersections in Real Time - 8,4
29. Matters of Honor - 8,4
30. Ship of Tears - 8,4
31. The Summoning - 8,4
32. Passing Through Gethsemane - 8,3
33. Signs and Portents - 8,3
34. Divided Loyalties - 8,2
35. Dust to Dust - 8,2
36. Moments of Transition - 8,2
37. The Hour of the Wolf - 8,2
38. Whatever Happened to Mr. Garibaldi? - 8,2
39. Comes the Inquisitor - 8,1
40. A Voice in the Wilderness: Part 2 - 8
41. Darkness Ascending - 8
42. Objects at Rest - 8
43. Objects in Motion - 8
44. Rumors, Bargains and Lies - 8
AND
1. Its Hour Come 'Round at Last - 8,2
2. Into the Labyrinth - 8
nBSG pilot
1. pilot 1 - 8,4
2. pilot 2 - 8,4
nBSG
1. Exodus: Part 2 - 9,2
2. Crossroads: Part 2 - 9,2
3. Revelations - 9,2
4. Blood on the Scales - 9,1
5. Pegasus - 9
6. The Oath - 9
7. Daybreak: Part 2 - 9
8. Resurrection Ship: Part 2 - 8,9
9. Kobol's Last Gleaming: Part 2 - 8,8
10. Lay Down Your Burdens: Part 2 - 8,7
11. Resurrection Ship: Part 1 - 8,7
12. Sometimes a Great Notion - 8,7
13. The Hub - 8,6
14. Daybreak: Part 3 - 8,6
15. 33 - 8,5
16. Guess What's Coming to Dinner - 8,5
17. Downloaded - 8,4
18. The Hand of God - 8,4
19. He That Believeth in Me - 8,4
20. No Exit - 8,4
21. Daybreak: Part 1 - 8,4
22. Home: Part 2 - 8,3
23. Kobol's Last Gleaming: Part 1 - 8,3
24. Crossroads: Part 1 - 8,3
25. Flight of the Phoenix - 8,2
26. Scattered - 8,2
27. You Can't Go Home Again - 8,2
28. Occupation - 8,2
29. Precipice - 8,2
30. Rapture - 8,2
31. Someone to Watch Over Me - 8,2
32. Exodus: Part 1 - 8,1
33. Collaborators - 8,1
34. The Eye of Jupiter - 8,1
35. Flesh and Bone - 8
36. Lay Down Your Burdens: Part 1 - 8
37. Resistance - 8
38. Faith - 8
ORV
1. Domino - 9,2
2. Identity - 9,1
3. Identity, Part II - 9
4. Twice in a Lifetime - 8,8
5. Lasting Impressions - 8,8
6. From Unknown Graves - 8,5
7. The Road Not Taken - 8,5
8. Mad Idolatry - 8,4
9. Gently Falling Rain - 8,3
10. Midnight Blue - 8,2
11. If the Stars Should Appear - 8,2
12. Majority Rule - 8,2
13. Nothing Left on Earth Excepting Fishes - 8,2
14. Sanctuary - 8,2
15. Tomorrow, and Tomorrow, and Tomorrow - 8,2
16. Future Unknown - 8,1
17. Home - 8,1
18. A Happy Refrain - 8,1
19. Firestorm - 8
B7
1. Blake - 8,8
2. Star One - 8,7
3. Terminal - 8,5
4. Rumours of Death - 8,4
5. Orbit - 8,3
6. City at the Edge of the World - 8,2
7. Pressure Point - 8,1
8. Space Fall - 8,1
9. Powerplay - 8
FSC
1. Into the Lion's Den: Part 2 - Wolf in Sheep's Clothing - 9
2. Die Me, Dichotomy - 8,9
3. Infinite Possibilities: Part 2 - Icarus Abides - 8,6
4. Liars, Guns and Money: Part 3: Plan B - 8,6
5. The Way We Weren't - 8,6
6. We're So Screwed: Part 3: La Bomba - 8,6
7. Into the Lion's Den: Part 1 - Lambs to the Slaughter - 8,5
8. Nerve - 8,5
9. The Hidden Memory - 8,5
10. We're So Screwed: Part 2: Hot to Katratzi - 8,5
11. A Human Reaction - 8,4
12. We're So Screwed: Part 1: Fetal Attraction - 8,4
13. Bad Timing - 8,3
14. Family Ties - 8,3
15. Liars, Guns and Money: Part 1: A Not So Simple Plan - 8,3
16. Terra Firma - 8,3
17. Incubator - 8,2
18. Liars, Guns and Money: Part 2: With Friends Like These... - 8,2
19. Season of Death - 8,2
20. Infinite Possibilities: Part 1 - Daedalus Demands - 8,1
21. Look at the Princess: Part 3: The Maltese Crichton - 8,1
22. Out of Their Minds - 8,1
23. Premiere - 8
24. Crackers Don't Matter - 8
25. Durka Returns - 8
26. I Shrink Therefore I Am - 8
27. Kansas - 8
28. Look at the Princess: Part 1: A Kiss Is But a Kiss - 8
29. Prayer - 8
30. Self Inflicted Wounds: Part 2 - Wait for the Wheel - 8
31. Won't Get Fooled Again - 8
FSC: TPW
1. The Peacekeeper Wars 2 - 8,6
2. The Peacekeeper Wars 1 - 8,3
No i Firefly w całości:
1. Out of Gas - 9,3
2. Objects in Space - 9,2
3. Ariel - 9
4. Our Mrs. Reynolds - 9
5. Serenity - 8,8
6. Trash - 8,8
7. War Stories - 8,8
8. Jaynestown - 8,7
9. Bushwhacked - 8,4
10. Shindig - 8,4
11. The Message - 8,4
12. The Train Job - 8,4
13. Heart of Gold - 8,3
14. Safe - 8,1
I jeszcze podobne odcinkowe noty dla dalszych krewnych Treka...
S:1999
1. Dragon's Domain - 8,3
SAAB
1. ...Tell Our Moms We Done Our Best - 8,8
2. The Angriest Angel - 8,6
3. Who Monitors the Birds? - 8,6
4. Sugar Dirt - 8,3
5. Never No More - 8
Lexx
1. Heaven and Hell - 8,3
2. Yo Way Yo - 8,3
3. Brigadoom - 8,2
4. The Game - 8,2
5. Battle - 8
Tymczasem w oczekiwaniu na 3 sezon PIC, Keith R.A. DeCandido obejrzał po raz któryś, i zrecenzował, INS i NEM:
https://www.tor.com/2023/02/13/picard-season-3-prelude-rewatching-star-trek-insurrection/
https://www.tor.com/2023/02/15/picard-season-3-prelude-rewatching-star-trek-nemesis/
A Steve Shives - który najwidoczniej zasmakował w omawianiu starych odcinków - zrecenzował TOS "Amok Time":
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I93Xzg8JpRA
I jeszcze jeden ranking filmów ST:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HHQ5Qp0oOuc
(Jak widać: można kochać i TMP z TWoK, i produkcje Abramsa, nawet "dwunastkę".)
Steve Shives omawia TNG "Chain of Command":
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xWCmjGZbFmE
Steve Shives omawia DS9 "The Visitor":
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wq5mjH0EkuU
Steve Shives omawia VOY "The Thaw":
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zv8dFRdZQPU
Steve Shives omawia ENT "Breaking the Ice":
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rohEUL2qWtE
Steve Shives omawia TAS "Yesteryear":
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MG9QlN-bt7k
I o najlepszych... otwarciach odcinków:
https://whatculture.com/film/10-best-star-trek-cold-opens-2
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4wC58YQx2Ss
Steve Shives omawia TNG "Unification":
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iFKKpsEnqQc
I o TNG "Conspiracy" też gada:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JtvszistwD8
Steve Shives omawia TNG "Relics":
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tX0Ff4f1cNk
O wspominanym już filmie "Pan i władca. Na krańcu świata" ("Master and Commander. The Far Side of the World") po raz kolejny:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dMv_LOGMZN0
Steve Shives omawia DS9 "Defiant":
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fsPF605ftlA
Pochwała ST III:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9deC-6lNv2g